RTD v SM

[TheNextCompanion]

Who do you prefer? Russell T Davies? Or Steven Moffat?

[judooning]

RTD without any hesitation.

[davros5comesback]

RTD without a doubt.

[TheNextCompanion]

RTD without any hesitation.

Good choice!

[The Eternal Dalek]

Steven Moffat, I just prefer the story style and the complex nature which isn't being used to explain why two characters look the same.

That isn't to say RTD can't write well he can, but his problem is that he writes a few good scenes and then has a dreadful one that ruins the whole thing.

[TheNextCompanion]

I guess RTD episodes are more fun. SM focuses on danger

[The Eternal Dalek]

I guess RTD episodes are more fun. SM focuses on danger

Not danger, his stories are darker than RTD's were. If RTD were to make a dark story it would be in Torchwood and rely on swearing and... other things.

[TheNextCompanion]

I guess RTD episodes are more fun. SM focuses on danger

Not danger, his stories are darker than RTD's were. If RTD were to make a dark story it would be in Torchwood and rely on swearing and... other things.

I dont like SM's style. He tries too hard

[GenosideDalek]

Steven Moffat, I just prefer the story style and the complex nature which isn't being used to explain why two characters look the same.

I completely agree with you, with an additional extra: RTD is rubbish.

[judooning]

Don't get me wrong, i love Steven Moffat's Work, but it's alaways time twisted and confusing. I want some stories that you can just follow and then put an end to that certain story after 45mins. This is what RTD mostly did. It's nice to have those confusing, mind boggling episodes, but not constantly.